New Castle, PA Real Estate Market 2026
New Castle is the 8th lowest of 34 Pennsylvania metros by median home price ($166,747). Data from Zillow ZHVI, FRED, Census ACS, and FEMA NRI. Data through October 2026.
$166,747
+4.7% year-over-year
7.9%
gross annual
+4.6%
base case (Zillow ZHVF)
+4.6% year-over-year
25/100
LowMarket Momentum
Net migration: Top 34% nationally
Income Migration
In-migrants avg $50,744 AGI vs out-migrants $53,973
Opportunity Zone Market
2 ZIP codes in New Castle are designated Qualified Opportunity Zones (IRC 1400Z-2), eligible for capital gains tax deferral on qualifying investments. Learn more →
New Castle Market Summary
New Castle differs most from the rest of Pennsylvania on median household income: $57,585, the 2nd lowest of 34 Pennsylvania metros, against a median of $64,034. At $166,747, the median home in New Castle costs 25% below the Pennsylvania median ($223,494) and 34% below the median US metro ($250,855). Over the past 12 months prices rose 4.7%, 1.4 points above the median Pennsylvania metro (+3.3%); 4 metros in Pennsylvania did better. Investors here get a 7.9% gross rental yield (median 6.0%, the 4th highest of 34) and a price-to-income ratio of 2.9 where the typical Pennsylvania metro sits at 3.4. On climate risk (25/100), 11 Pennsylvania metros score worse and 1 better. The Pennsylvania metros priced closest to it are Sunbury ($163,610) and Meadville ($163,576). Outside Pennsylvania, Huntington-Ashland, WV-KY-OH and Peoria, IL have the nearest mix of price and rental yield.
How New Castle compares
34 Pennsylvania metros, 894 US metros. Rank 1 = highest.
| Metric | New Castle | Pennsylvania median | US median | Rank in Pennsylvania | Rank in US |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Median home price | $166,747 | $223,494 | $250,855 | 27/34 | 763/894 |
| Price change, past 12 months | +4.7% | +3.3% | +2.1% | 5/34 | 122/894 |
| Gross rental yield | 7.9% | 6.0% | 6.0% | 4/34 | 100/800 |
| Price-to-income ratio | 2.9x | 3.4x | 3.9x | 24/34 | 770/894 |
| Median household income | $57,585 | $64,034 | $64,742 | 33/34 | 666/894 |
| Climate risk score (FEMA NRI) | 25/100 | 25/100 | 25/100 | 12/34 | 338/889 |
Affordability
Price Forecast Scenarios
12-month projection (Zillow ZHVF model)
Climate & Natural Hazard Risk
New Castle, PA's primary climate exposure is flooding (50/100). The composite climate risk score of 25/100 (Low) indicates overall risk reflecting favorable conditions for long-term real estate investment. This market benefits from relatively low natural hazard exposure compared to coastal and wildfire-prone regions.
Source: FEMA National Risk Index
Other markets in Pennsylvania
Median price · 12-month change · gross yield, for each list below.
- Lewistown, PA$194,688+5.2%4.9%
- Pottsville, PA$179,748+4.4%7.9%
- Somerset, PA$178,493+5.2%5.2%
- Huntingdon, PA$173,781+0.7%6.1%
- Altoona, PA$172,346+4.9%6.7%
- Indiana, PA$171,749+8.6%13.0%
- Sunbury, PA$163,610+0.9%7.3%
- Meadville, PA$163,576+4.6%6.3%
- Warren, PA$139,153+2.7%7.8%
- DuBois, PA$137,991+4.0%7.6%
- Oil City, PA$128,137-0.5%6.9%
- Johnstown, PA$115,086+3.4%9.2%
Markets like New Castle in other states
- Huntington-Ashland, WV-KY-OH$165,261+1.6%7.9%
- Peoria, IL$171,129+5.5%7.9%
- Fairmont, WV$163,102+2.5%8.0%
- Monroe, LA$167,871+3.7%8.1%
- Murray, KY$168,556-6.2%8.1%
- Beeville, TX$158,248-0.7%7.9%
- Moultrie, GA$166,198+4.7%8.2%
- Talladega-Sylacauga, AL$178,069+0.1%7.9%
- Muskogee, OK$156,043+2.8%7.9%
- Dublin, GA$169,726+4.8%7.7%
- Danville, VA$163,417+0.7%7.7%
- Tiffin, OH$180,583+5.1%7.9%
Get the full New Castle dataset
Migration flows, ZIP-level neighborhood data, full demographics, price history, and the Market Screener.