New Castle, IN Real Estate Market 2026
New Castle is the 9th lowest of 36 Indiana metros by median home price ($189,782). Data from Zillow ZHVI, FRED, Census ACS, and FEMA NRI. Data through October 2026.
$189,782
+2.9% year-over-year
5.4%
gross annual
+2.8%
base case (Zillow ZHVF)
+2.8% year-over-year
25/100
LowMarket Momentum
Net migration: Top 38% nationally
Income Migration
In-migrants avg $49,009 AGI vs out-migrants $47,529
Opportunity Zone Market
1 ZIP codes in New Castle are designated Qualified Opportunity Zones (IRC 1400Z-2), eligible for capital gains tax deferral on qualifying investments. Learn more →
New Castle Market Summary
New Castle differs most from the rest of Indiana on median home price: $189,782, the 9th lowest of 36 Indiana metros, against a median of $230,769. Over the past 12 months prices rose 2.9%, 1.2 points below the median Indiana metro (+4.1%); 27 metros in Indiana did better. Investors here get a 5.4% gross rental yield (median 6.0%, the 8th lowest of 30) and a price-to-income ratio of 3.2 where the typical Indiana metro sits at 3.4. On climate risk (25/100), 5 Indiana metros score worse and 14 better. The Indiana metros priced closest to it are Wabash ($190,201) and Kokomo ($191,018). Outside Indiana, Russellville, AR and Emporia, KS have the nearest mix of price and rental yield.
How New Castle compares
36 Indiana metros, 894 US metros. Rank 1 = highest.
| Metric | New Castle | Indiana median | US median | Rank in Indiana | Rank in US |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Median home price | $189,782 | $230,769 | $250,855 | 28/36 | 676/894 |
| Price change, past 12 months | +2.9% | +4.1% | +2.1% | 28/36 | 315/894 |
| Gross rental yield | 5.4% | 6.0% | 6.0% | 23/30 | 557/800 |
| Price-to-income ratio | 3.2x | 3.4x | 3.9x | 25/36 | 689/894 |
| Median household income | $60,144 | $65,584 | $64,742 | 27/36 | 591/894 |
| Climate risk score (FEMA NRI) | 25/100 | 25/100 | 25/100 | 6/36 | 338/889 |
Affordability
Price Forecast Scenarios
12-month projection (Zillow ZHVF model)
Climate & Natural Hazard Risk
New Castle, IN's primary climate exposure is tornadoes (50/100). The composite climate risk score of 25/100 (Low) indicates overall risk reflecting favorable conditions for long-term real estate investment. This market benefits from relatively low natural hazard exposure compared to coastal and wildfire-prone regions.
Source: FEMA National Risk Index
Other markets in Indiana
Median price · 12-month change · gross yield, for each list below.
- Evansville, IN-KY$224,157+3.4%5.6%
- North Vernon, IN$222,717+4.0%
- Huntington, IN$210,765+4.4%4.5%
- Bedford, IN$205,972+1.0%6.0%
- Kokomo, IN$191,018+3.3%6.9%
- Wabash, IN$190,201+4.2%
- Richmond, IN$174,417+6.1%6.1%
- Logansport, IN$172,143+3.4%5.5%
- Muncie, IN$168,975+4.4%7.3%
- Terre Haute, IN$164,700+1.4%7.4%
- Peru, IN$160,632+5.2%6.9%
- Vincennes, IN$158,960+4.5%
Markets like New Castle in other states
- Russellville, AR$196,774+3.1%5.4%
- Emporia, KS$189,233+2.4%5.2%
- Scottsbluff, NE$198,941+3.2%5.4%
- Mansfield, OH$197,090+5.2%5.5%
- Kirksville, MO$190,742+3.7%5.0%
- Somerset, PA$178,493+5.2%5.2%
- Clinton, IA$179,908+6.2%5.6%
- Weatherford, OK$174,784+2.3%5.5%
- Lock Haven, PA$197,955+1.1%5.7%
- Lewistown, PA$194,688+5.2%4.9%
- Fairfield, IA$179,390+1.3%5.0%
- Farmington, MO$192,959+2.1%5.9%
Get the full New Castle dataset
Migration flows, ZIP-level neighborhood data, full demographics, price history, and the Market Screener.